Uniwersyteckie Czasopisma NaukoweWyzwania metodologiczne historii konstytucyjnej w Europie Środkowo-Wschodniej
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2025.3.02Słowa kluczowe:
rumuńska historia konstytucyjna, porównawcza historia prawa, powszechna historia prawa, tendencja tożsamości konstytucyjnej, imitacja, interdyscyplinarnośćAbstrakt
W artykule dokonano pogłębionej analizy rumuńskiego procesu modernizacji konstytucyjnej w kontekście dążenia rumuńskich elit do uformowania tożsamości w XIX i na początku XX w. Autor dąży do rozwikłania problemu, dlaczego rumuńska tożsamość narodowa i konstytucyjna została ukształtowana przez wiele konkurujących narracji skonstruowanych przez rumuńską inteligencję – w tym celu analizuje najlepsze narzędzia metodologiczne do oceny tego procesu. W opracowaniu skrótowo oceniono metodologiczną bazę porównawczej historii prawa i powszechnej historii prawa oraz mocno podkreślono pilną potrzebę większej interdyscyplinarności. Nauki społeczne mogą zapewnić niezbędne tło analityczne, ułatwiając podejście do rumuńskiej historii konstytucyjnej w sposób porównawczy (w przestrzeni), historyczny (w czasie) i psychosocjologiczny (w umysłach).
Downloads
Bibliografia
Banciu A., Constituție și identitate la români, “Sfera Politicii” 2018, no. 3–4.
Blokker P., Modernity and its varieties. A historical, sociological analysis of the Romanian modern experience, Florence 2004, https://cadmus.eui.eu/handle/1814/5240 [accessed: 2024.05.17].
Boia L., De ce este România altfel?, 2nd ed., București 2013.
Boia L., Istorie și mit în conștiința românească, București 2010.
van Caenegem R.C., A Historical Introduction to Western Constitutional Law, Cambridge 1996.
Carp R., Responsabilitatea ministerială, București 2003.
Cinpoeș R., Nationalism and Identity in Romania, London 2010.
De ce este România altfel. Avatarurile excepționalismului Românesc, ed. V. Mihăilescu, Iași 2017.
Delpérée F., Le droit constitutionnel de la Belgique, Bruxelles 2000.
Discovering the Unexpected. Comparative Legal Studies in Eastern and Central Europe, eds. W. Butler, O.V. Kresin, New Jersey 2021.
Drace-Francis A., The Making of Modern Romanian Culture. Literacy and the Development of National Identity, London–New York 2006.
Drace-Francis A., The Traditions of Invention Romanian Ethnic and Social Stereotypes in Historical Context, Leiden 2013.
Duțu M., Un secol de ştiinţă a dreptului şi de cultură juridică în România (1918–2018), “Studii și Cercetări Juridice – Serie Nouă” 2018, no. 4.
Duve T., Entanglements in Legal History. Introductory Remarks [in:] Entanglements in Legal History: Conceptual Approaches, ed. idem, Frankfurt am Main 2014.
Duve T., Global Legal History: A Methodological Approach [in:] Oxford Handbook Topics in Law, 2017, https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199935352.013.25 [accessed: 2024.05.17].
Gałędek M., Remarks on the Methodology of Comparative Legal Research in the Context of the History of Law in Poland, “Acta Universitatis Lodziensis. Folia Juridica” 2022, vol. 99.
Gilissen J., La Constitution belge de 1831: ses sources, son influence, “Res Publica” 1968, vol. 10.
Gosewinkel D., The Constitutional State [in:] The Oxford Handbook of European Legal History, eds. H. Pihlajamäki, M.D. Dubber, M. Godfrey, Oxford 2018.
Greenfeld L., Nationalism. Five Roads to Modernity, Cambridge, Massachusetts 1993.
Guțan M., A Failed Constitutional Experiment: The Monarchical Constitutionalism and the Organic Regulations of 1831–1832, “Journal of Constitutional History” 2021, vol. 42.
Guțan M., Administrative (Authoritarian) Monarchy – A Paradigm for the Constitutional Realism in Modern Romania? [in:] Iustitia et Pax. Gedächtnisschrift für prof. Dr. Dieter Blumenwitz, eds. G. Gornig, B. Schöbener, W. Bausback, T.H. Irmscher, Berlin 2008.
Guțan M., Constitutional Identity as Competing Historically Driven Narratives: Central and European Perspectives [in:] Law, Culture and Identity in Central and Eastern Europe. A Comparative Engagement, eds. C. Cercel, A. Mercescu, M.M. Sadowski, New York 2023.
Guțan M., Legal Transplant as Socio-Cultural Engineering in Modern Romania [in:] Konflikt und Koexistenz. Die Rechtsordnungen Sudosteuropas im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert. Band I: Rumanien, Bulgarien, Griechenland, eds. M. Stolleis, G. Bender, J. Kirov, Frankfurt am Main 2015.
Guțan M., Națiunea asediată: constituționalismul etnocentric românesc și migrația contemporană, “Revista de drept public” 2017, special issue.
Guțan M., The Challenges of the Romanian Constitutional Tradition. II. Between Constitutional Transplant and (Failed) Cultural Engineering, “Journal of Constitutional History” 2013, vol. 26.
Guțan M., The Concept of Imitation and Its Epistemological Relevance in Comparative Law and Comparative Legal History, “The Journal of Comparative Law” 2024, vol. 19(1).
Guțan M., The Legal Transplant and the Building of the Romanian Legal Identity in the Second Half of the 19th Century and the Beginning of the 20th Century, “Romanian Journal of Comparative Law” 2018, vol. 8.
Guțan M., Transplant constituțional și constituționalism în România modernă 1802–1866, București 2013.
Iordachi C., Liberalism, Constitutional Nationalism, and Minorities, Brill 2019.
Kissane B., Sitter N., National Identity and Constitutions in Modern Europe: Into the Fifth Zone [in:] Comparative Constitution Making, eds. D. Landau, H. Lerner, Cheltenham–Northampton 2019.
Livezeanu I., Cultură și naționalism în România Mare, București 1998.
Maner H.-C., Parlamentarismul în România 1930–1940 [Parliamentarianism in Romania 1930– 1940], București 2004.
Marton S., La construction politique de la nation. La nation dans les débats du Parlement de la Roumanie (1866–1871), Iași 2009.
Matiuța C., Naționalism și liberalism la mijlocul secolului XIX [in:] Liberalismul românesc și valențele sale europene, ed. L. Brătescu, 2nd ed., Iași 2013.
Milanov M., The Region Without Qualities. Fiction, International Law and Internalized Irrelevance of Central and Eastern Europe [in:] Law, Culture and Identity in Central and Eastern Europe a Comparative Engagement, eds. C. Cercel, A. Mercescu, M.M. Sadowski, New York 2023.
Momoc A., Capcanele politice ale sociologiei interbelice. Școala gustiană între carlism și Legionarism, București 2012.
Neumann, V., Conceptually Mystified: East-Central Europe Torn Between Ethnocentrism and Recognition of Multiple Identities, București 2004.
Neumann V., Essays on Romanian Intellectual History, Iași 2013.
Padoa-Schioppa A., A History of Law in Europe. From the Early Middle Ages to the Twentieth Century, Cambridge 2017.
Pihlajamäki H., Comparative Contexts in Legal History: Are We All Comparatists Now? [in:] The Method and Culture of Comparative Law, eds. M. Adams, D. Heirbaut, Oxford–Portland, Oregon 2015.
Platon Gh., Liberalismul românesc în secolul al XIX-lea. Emergență, etape, forme de expresie [in:] idem, De la constituirea națiunii la marea unire. Studii de istorie modernă, vol. 2, Iași 1998.
Preuss U.K., The Exercise of Constituent Power in Central and Eastern Europe [in:] The Paradox of Constitutionalism. Constituent Power and Constitutional Form, eds. M. Loughlin, N. Walker, Oxford 2008.
Rusu M.S., Memoria națională românească. Facerea și prefacerile discursive ale trecutului national, Iași 2015.
Schmidt K.I., From Evolutionary Functionalism to Critical Transnationalism. Comparative Legal History, Aristotle to Present [in:] The Oxford Handbook of Legal History, eds. M.D. Dubber, C. Tomlins, Oxford 2018.
Sledzinska-Simon A., Constitutional identity in 3D: A model of individual, relational and collective self and its application in Poland, “I-CON” 2015, vol. 13.
The Oxford Handbook of European Legal History, eds. H. Pihlajamäki, M.D. Dubber, M. Godfrey, Oxford 2018.
Theodoresco A., La nouvelle constitution de la Roumanie, “Bulletin mensuel de la Société de Législation Comparé” 1926, no. 4–6.
Turda M., Eugenism și modernitate. Națiune, rasă și biopolitică în Europa (1870–1950), Iași 2014.
Verdery K., National Ideology and National Character in Interwar Romania [in:] National Ideology and National Character in Interwar Eastern Europe, eds. I. Banac, K. Verdery, Yale 1995.
Pobrania
Opublikowane
Jak cytować
Numer
Dział
Licencja
Prawa autorskie (c) 2025 Gdańskie Studia Prawnicze
Utwór dostępny jest na licencji Creative Commons Uznanie autorstwa – Użycie niekomercyjne – Bez utworów zależnych 4.0 Międzynarodowe.
